What was your response to PROJECTTrio?
Those performances (in the recital hour and in Kresge) were not typical classical music concerts. How were they different? How were they similar? What did you like? What didn't you like?
Could classical concerts be more like that? Should classical concerts be more like that?
Let's discuss.
I absolutely loved Project Trio! It was such a cool, fun, inspiring show. I think it's so awesome that they incorporate classical composers into their show in an exciting way that makes it enjoyable for everyone. The show had a much more laid back feel than a typical classical music concert, and I think that people who are not classical music lovers appreciate that more. There really was not anything I didn't like about the group. They were funny, talented, and played great music. I really liked how they would take a classical piece and make it their own by messing with the tempo and dynamics. I also thought it was really cool how they all used their instrument in a unique way - the flute player beatboxing, the cellist playing it like an electric guitar, and the bassist playing his like a drum.
ReplyDeleteProject Trio does a great job of making classical music appeal to everyone. However, I do not think that classical concerts should be like that. I believe it would take away from the original art. Yes, maybe more people would come to see the concerts but the music that Project Trio and we all fell in love with would not be presented in the way it was made to be presented. I think more classical musicians could make a show like Project Trio's and be successful, but it should be a separate show from classical concerts.
Project Trio was absolutely awesome! I appreciated getting to learn about their experiences first and then getting to hear them in action. Knowing some about their background and personal experiences with forming and running the group made the concert seem even better. I strongly encouraged several of my CLA friends to go to the concert, and the ones who went absolutely loved it. I was really happy to see that Project Trio appealed to them as CLA majors in addition to all of us.
ReplyDeleteThe evening concert was different than typical classical music concerts primarily because of the energy the guys had on stage. They looked like they were having the time of their lives, and that enthusiastic vibe spread out to the audience too. Project Trio also interacted more with the audience than in a typical classical music concert. However, their instrumentation and songs were similar to that of a classical concert. Admittedly, the combination of a flute, cello, and bass is unusual,and each was played in a different way than they would have been in a traditional classical music setting, but they are all still classical instruments. Some of their song choices were classical pieces as well. It was fun to hear their versions of them! That and listening to the rewritten Peter and the Wolf story were probably my favorite parts. I think my favorite piece though was the Cherry Blossom one, it was so beautiful and hearing them describe the setting beforehand completed it.
I think classical concerts could be like that, but shouldn't be necessarily. I really appreciate that Project Trio and other groups are bridging the gap between classical and "other" genres; I think that's a great thing to be doing and more people should do it. It brings the trained musicians and non-musicians together in a unique setting, which is wonderful. However, I also think that "normal" classical music still has its own merit and values. It's fun to hear different interpretations of traditional classical pieces, but the classical works in their original form should still exist and be performed. There is plenty of room in the musical world for both classical and "classical plus" concerts to happen, and I think they both should.
The idea of classically-trained musicians creating something new out of something old is thrilling. It was inspiring to watch Project Trio play with such passion, inspiring to hear them speak about their careers, past, present and future, with passion. Yes, their stylistic approach was unconventional, but they played so that all people could appreciate their music.
ReplyDeleteEven after seeing YouTube videos of Project Trio, seeing them perform in person was not what I expected. Their casual approach to classical music set them aside from typical orchestra players and concert musicians that I frequently see. But their basic playing was the same as any classically-trained musician.
Classical concerts should not be like Project Trio concerts. The refined playing that you find in classical concerts is something that cannot be taken away from the classical music that we have come to know and love. Project Trio has incredible talent, and their talent will always set them apart from strictly classical playing.
When I think about PROJECT Trio, I think of three ordinary people playing extraordinary music. They have combined so many musical elements into this enjoyable performance, which wow-ed me in great extent. I absolutely LOVED it!!
ReplyDeleteComparing the performances with typical classical concerts, I would say they are more... interesting. The group gave new "faces" to the classical music we used to hear. Both concerts have a "down-to-earth" atmosphere. They were extremely friendly and energetic - something that I could hardly ever find in general classical concerts. Interestingly, the program of both concerts were announced instead of printed. This, therefore, curiosity and suspense were created, and resolved by surprises in the performances. The concert was performed as a trio, but a very different combination - a flute, a cello, and a string bass. Yet, what they performed were just so... normal - not ordinary, but just like what you would hear in a normal concert. I could not express how much I was awestruck. One of the things that I like is the enthusiasm and energy beaming on the performers' faces. I could tell that they were enjoying immensely in the performance. Another thing, in particular, is the pieces of "Cherry Blossom" and "Peter and the Wolf". I got goosebumps all over!
Could classical concerts be more like that? I don't think so. Should classical concerts be more like that? Definitely "no". I love diversity. I love how PROJECT Trio performs, but I also like classical performances. Each of them have their own beauty - one embraces improvisation, while the other shows appreciation of previous works. If classical performances are similar to PROJECT Trio's performance, what is the point of having various genres? Vice versa, it would be pathetic if improvisation does not bring inspirational perspectives to classical music. I personally think that both should co-exist to fulfill different types of audience.
One fun fact - PROJECT Trio have been to Hong Kong before!! Why didn't I go to the concert?
I thoroughly enjoyed Project Trio. Their energy on stage, their movement, their jazzed-up renditions of classics, and their original work was wonderful. However, I was not surprised by their performance, because I have seen them perform live at my high school.
ReplyDeleteWhat struck me most about the Project Trio was how they formed their group and got their business rolling. Their development was a long process with lots of hard work. I had no idea that Project Trio didn't have a marketing team or a manager. The fact that they put their unique product out there all by themselves is amazing.
Project Trio does a wonderful job at making music that can appeal to all audiences. Their hip style and general enthusiasm paired with excellent musicianship has created a powerful ensemble. I love their movement/ stage presence because it greatly differs from a traditional classical performance. They were similar to classical performances however in level of ability.
I could not honestly say that I disliked any of their performance. I would not want their career as my own though. The constant traveling and unsteady income would be too stressful for me personally. I applaud them for making their product successful!
My first thought of Project Trio was that they were a group of classically trained musicicans that were here to play classical music. After recital hour however, all I could think about was how exciting the concert was going to be.Project Trio is a group that brought smiles to a ton of faces that day, mine included. It's not everyday that I see a guy playing the flute and beat boxing at the same time. That cannot be an easy thing to do. My favorite part of the concert and Project Trio was the energy that they could bring into a room by their performance. They moved with their music.I would definitley go see them again.
ReplyDeleteEvery performance of music has something that makes it unique. Project for instance played different classical music on classical instruments. Others may play classical music on any instrument of their choice. The key here is choice. Project chose the music that they played for a reason. A performance could become classical, it has to be a choice of the performer though is what it comes down to.
Audiences also play a big role in a performers choice on how classical the music choice should be. Most younger audiences woud prefer the type of music that Project Trio performed. Everyone has their own opinion. There are a lot of things that performers need to take into consideration before a show. In my opinion I don't think all classical performances should be like that. I enjoy both types so I would happily attend both. There is the word genre like Crystal said for a reason.
I really really loved Project Trio, they were so dynamic together, they created a fun environment where you could enjoy there music without feeling any of the stuffiness or the "etiquette" that you feel is sometimes required when in classical music concerts. My favorite performer was the bassist, because he looked like he loved the music the best, like he was having the time of his life performing, and it made me feel like I was having the time of my life watching him perform.
ReplyDeleteI love classical music, and I love going to classical music concerts, but more and more people don't have that much of an interest in it. Classical music needs to find a way to appeal to a younger audience but I don't necessarily think that the way Project Trio does it is the way Classical music has to change with the times.
I unfortunately did not have the opportunity to attend the concert, but I loved their performance at Recital Hour. Project Trio has a really unique approach to music, and I love that. I love that they do not follow the traditional way of having a concert. They do not care about be dressed nicely for their concerts or having complete silence. In my opinion they just want to go on stage and have fun making music in front of other people who love to make music as well.
ReplyDeleteI am not completely sure if classical music concerts could go that far out, but there needs to be a change to appeal to the younger audiences. Today's younger generation is always on the go and want to see what is new and they need to keep up.
I absolutely loved Project Trio! I thought they were incredibly talented musicians, great performers, and they had an inspiring story. Their unique style and repertoire were so interesting! I didn't want either concert to end! They were a lot more laid back than most classical music concerts, which I liked most of the time. I wish that the flautist had maybe worn a button-up shirt with his jeans, like the others, just so it seemed like he cared a bit more. But I did really like that they were in jeans; it made the atmosphere very relaxed. I think that more informal attire would be a nice addition to a classical concert. Often times I think that "non-music" people are intimidated by the atmosphere, thinking that they are not welcome if they don't completely understand, and more informal attire may help it be less intimidating. In addition, the informal way in which Project Trio talked to the audience could be easily applied to a classical concert. As far as musical content, however, I think that perhaps a combination of normal classical and fusion would be good and keep the audience's attention.
ReplyDeleteI thought Project Trio was incredible! They had so much energy, passion, and technique displayed within their show. It is one of the first instrumental concerts that I've not fallen asleep during! I really enjoyed the large mixture of styles they incorporated into their playing. I think it liked Cherry Blossom the best, but I was really impressed with the rap song, along with everything else, of course! Another thing I found interesting was their formal apparel. It's nice to see musicians wearing what they're comfortable playing in, and it's equally as nice to not have to wear a suit just to go watch a performance. It was very laid back.
ReplyDeleteI believe it was the passion that they played with that won me over. All of them were very into what they were doing individually, as well as in a group. Each one moved, played with their own style, and most importantly - to me - enjoyed every note that they played.
It was a truly incredible performance, and I really didn't want it to end. I hope all the musicians that come to DePauw in the near future have a similar impact.
Project Trio was one of the most fun concerts I've been to in a while! They have incredible talent and an awesome story but that's just the beginning. What really stood out to me was how modest and down-to-earth they were. I love how they interact with the audience not only between but during pieces as well. The way they talk to audience is personal and encouraging. Project Trio's casual dress also speaks to the audience in a way that says "Anyone can be creative or follow their dreams." I was really disappointed when I had to leave early but I'll be sure to catch them the next chance I get!
ReplyDeleteI think their style is a necessity for attracting younger audiences to classical music especially in this age. However, I think there is a certain line that any performer should stay behind when working with such iconic and classical music. Unfortunately, where the line exactly lies is a little blurry. In my opinion, as long as the piece's original intent and integrity is in tact, then it's okay to get a little creative with it.
I thought project trio was fantastic! I loved the energy they had on stage, they really pulled the audience into their performance. I also loved how they took classical songs from Bethoven, Bach, Brahms and made them "project trio" style with the beat-boxing flute. All three musicians have extensive musical training and it really shows when they play. I have never heard the "seagull" thing on the cello before and I thought the way he used it in his hip-hop piece was very creative and really got the audience cheering. The vibe that these performers give off is welcoming and non judgmental. Often times when people go to concerts they get the feeling that the people on stage think they are better than them so they don't enjoy the concert. But Project Trio gave off a feeling of everyone being on the same level, they did not give off the impression that they were "better" than the people sitting in the audience. In fact they encouraged the people in the audience to go off and try to form a group like Project Trio and become the next big thing. I think this is why people enjoy watching them perform so much, because Project Trio makes people feel like they CAN do what they are doing and even go beyond with enough determination and hard work.
ReplyDeleteWhen I was describing Project Trio to my friends, I couldn't explain them! I found it difficult because they do such different music style. I enjoyed the performance so much and I have found my "idols". They are amazing musicians and also enjoy what they are doing. While watching their performance it was really nice to see performers who didn't look as stuck up and just interacted with the audience. Most of my friends would be like "Hey look at the bass player, his expressions are priceless!". He knew what he was doing and it made the audience feel at ease when they performed because he wanted to show how much fun he was having. Honestly though, I don't think Project Trio is trying to attract to a certain audience, they seem like the type of people who would say "I'm going to play what I want, and if you don't like it so be it". That attitude is awesome because they don't have to change themselves to be more liked or more famous.
ReplyDelete